Israel Supreme Court rules that providing clothes amounts to material support to a terrorist organisation

The Court ruled on 28 September 2008 that the Defence Minister’s decision, under Regulation 84(2)(b) of the Defense Regulations (State of Emergency) 1945, to issue a confiscation order against a container full of clothes and backpacks that was delivered to a trader in the Gaza Strip from his son in China, was a legitimate decision.

From the International Law Observer:

The Court examined the secret material which constituted the basis for the Defense Minister’s decision to confiscate the container. The judgment states that from the material the justices were able to discern that the delivery was for “a charity organization which is part of the organization of the Palestinian Islamic jihad terror group, which was outlawed for being an illegal association.” According to the State’s submissions, the delivery of such support parcels is “one of the [terror group’s] ways to aid and support its people and their families”.

The Justices persist, “in this state of affairs, in the presence of overwhelming administrative evidence and considering the discretion granted to the Defense Minister, we did not see a basis to interfere with the decision.” Most appallingly, the Court stated that it was informed by the State Attorney that “the confiscated delivery will be handed over to the Palestinian Authority for the purpose of its distribution.”

The only ground presented by the Court to justify the reasoning of its decision was that pertaining to the secret evidence, which had in this case, unlike in previous ones, attested to a relation between the delivery and a terror organization. The justices, Beinisch, Rivlin and Arbel, equally used this opportunity to confirm the longstanding discretion granted to state officials in the exercise of their authority when matters of state security are at hand. This is a characteristic decision for the Israeli Supreme Court (the complaints body for the occupation regime in the occupied Palestinian territories).

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: