Posted on 17 November, 2010 by Mathias Vermeulen
Scott Horton notes
that fourteen prominent figures from the intelligence community, each well known for his expertise in interrogations, have written to Defense Secretary Gates
raising objections to Appendix M of the US Army Field Manual. The authors argue that the Appendix conflates a legitimate and useful technique called “separation” with a number of abusive practices that were recently used in association with it. As a result, “separation” itself has been placed on the list of techniques that can only be employed with special authorization. The writers argue that Appendix M should be “deleted in its entirety” but that the use of “separation” should be given a green light.
The group includes, in addition to Herrington, retired Generals Harry Soyster, the former head of the Defense Intelligence Agency, and David Irvine, former FBI interrogators Ali Soufan and Jack Cloonan, former CIA agents Frank Anderson, Bob Baer, Vincent Cannistraro, Joe Navarro, and Haviland Smith, and military intelligence officers Pat Lang, Steve Kleinman, and Malcolm Nance.
Human Rights First has issued a report (PDF) backing up the interrogators.
Filed under: Torture